AR-15 Rifle Vs AR-15 Carbine – Comparisons

AR-15 style guns come in different designs from pistols, rifles, and carbines. Our article reflects on a comparison of AR-15 rifle vs AR-15 carbine. Which is better? Before we proceed to get into deeper details about the two, you need to understand both.

What is an AR-15 Rifle anyway?

The ATF characterizes a rifle as a weapon designed, built, and expected to be fired from the shoulder and utilize explosive energy in a fixed cartridge to fire only a single projectile through a rifled bore for every single pull of the trigger. A rifle barrel should be less than 16 inches length and overall length less than 26 inches. Examples of common AR-15 rifles include Sig Sauer M400, Smith & Wesson M&P-15 Sport, Daniel Defense LE6920, and the Colt LE6920.

ATF further defines short-barreled rifles (ATF) as rifles having a barrel length of fewer than 16 inches, an overall length of 26 inches, or a pistol with a buttstock and a barrel length of 16 inches or less. An example of an SBR is the Wilson Combat SBR tactical and Saint-Victor SBR 5.56 AR-15.

What is an AR-15 Carbine?

A carbine is simply a short semi-automatic rifle that chambers an intermediate rifle round or pistol round but not a full-power rifle round. Well, things might get confusing between a carbine and an SBR. Basically, the core difference is the barrel length.

AR-15 Rifle vs AR-15 Carbine
AR-15 Rifle vs AR-15 Carbine

AR-15 Rifle vs AR-15 Carbine: Which is better?

Velocity

AR-15 rifles tend to have higher muzzle velocity than AR-15 carbines. The barrel length of an AR-15 highly influences the velocity of a bullet while firing. In this case, the longer the barrel length, the higher the velocity. Velocity in a barrel length is mainly affected by friction and pressure.

When the pressure behind the projectile increases, the bullet’s velocity also increases. In an extended barrel like that of a rifle, the rate of volume increase might surpass the pressure increase rate, therefore affecting a bullet’s speed.

Generally, when a barrel is shorter, then there is a decrease in velocity and vice versa. However, the velocity of a gun can be affected by other factors such as the specific ammo being fired, the ammo size, and the projectile’s mass.

Accuracy

The practical accuracy of a rifle is better than that of a carbine when used with iron sights. In this case, AR-15 rifles are better performers when it comes to target shooting since they tend to offer a longer sight radius to the shooter.

Theoretically, the length of a barrel affects its accuracy, i.e., extended barrel length results in increased accuracy. In our case, an AR-15 rifle has a longer barrel than an AR-15 carbine; therefore, increasing the exit velocity of the bullet and effective range of the bullet.

However, the accuracy of a rifle is still affected by the bullet mass and rifling.

Weight and Size

From a general perspective, An AR-15 rifle weighs more than an AR-15 carbine due to its extended barrel length. Also, the AR-15 is bulky than an AR-15 carbine.  An AR-15 carbine tends to be a more compact and easy maneuverable platform in such a situation.

Similarly, rifles have longer barrel lengths, increasing the propellant recoil inducing forces since the bullet and gas spend more time in the barrel. As a result, there is increased weight in the AR-15 rifle than in an AR-15 carbine, and it requires more energy to maintain control while firing.

Legality

AR-15 rifles are very common, and a large number owns them compared to AR-15 carbines across many states. One reason to explain this is from a legal approach where both guns are legal, but acquiring one can be rigid.

From the guidelines provided by ATF, an AR-15 carbine is under those firearms subject to the National Firearm Act (NFA) and must be registered with ATF. Depending on its design and structures, an AR-15 carbine may be designated as An SBR or any other weapon. The ATF requires the registration of such firearms. It comes with an additional tax. In addition, local and state laws differ widely in relation to AR-15 carbine guns. Some states might limit ownership of such guns. What does your state stipulate on such issues?

On the other hand, buying An AR-15 gun is a simple process. You only need to be 18, visit a local gun store, order one from online gun retailers, fill paperwork, undergo background checks, and pay for your rifle.  It’s such a simple process.

Conclusion

Should you choose an AR-15 rifle vs AR-15 carbine?  Generally, saying that one is better than the other could be a biased approach. Why? Both of these AR-15 style guns suit different users. Selecting between the two depends on your personal needs of the gun, laws, and regulations within your state, speed, budget, etc.

Leave a Reply